Northern Kingdoms and the Tripartite Struggle
Early medieval north India for UPSC — Harsha, Palas, Pratiharas and Rashtrakutas, Rajput dynasties and temples, Kashmir, Arabs, Ghaznavids and Ghurids.
SyllabusGS I · History of India (Prelims); Indian culture — salient aspects of art forms, literature and architecture from ancient to modern times (Mains GS I)
Prerequisites: The Gupta Age · Chapter overview
The Hook: One City, Three Empires
In 643 CE King Harshavardhana held a great assembly at Kannauj, where the Chinese pilgrim Hiuen Tsang (Xuanzang) expounded Mahayana Buddhism before kings and scholars. Within a century of Harsha’s death, Kannauj had become the prize of north Indian politics — fought over for some two hundred years by the Palas of Bengal, the Gurjara-Pratiharas of western India and the Rashtrakutas of the Deccan.
The question this raises: why did a single city matter so much — and how did an age of constant war also produce Khajuraho, Konark, Vikramashila and the Rajatarangini?
The Core Concept
Harshavardhana (606–647 CE)
- Belonged to the Pushyabhuti (Vardhana) family of Thanesar. When his sister Rajyashri’s husband, the Maukhari king of Kannauj, was killed and his brother Rajyavardhana was murdered by Shashanka of Gauda, Harsha took both thrones and moved his capital to Kannauj. His accession in 606 CE began the Harsha era.
- Checked in the south: defeated by the Chalukya king Pulakeshin II on the Narmada — recorded in the Aihole inscription (634 CE) composed by Ravikirti.
- Patron and author: wrote three Sanskrit plays — Ratnavali, Priyadarshika and Nagananda. His court poet Banabhatta wrote the Harshacharita (a biography) and Kadambari.
- Religion: styled a devotee of Shiva (parama-maheshvara) in his copper plates, and a generous patron of Buddhism; held assemblies at Kannauj (643) and, according to Hiuen Tsang, a great distribution of wealth every five years at Prayag.
- Administration: looser than the Guptas’; Hiuen Tsang notes that officials were paid with grants of land and that revenue was one-sixth of the produce.
- Hiuen Tsang (in India c. 630–645) studied at Nalanda and left a detailed record of his travels (the Si-yu-ki). The Banskhera copper plate is notable for bearing what appears to be Harsha’s own signature.
The tripartite struggle for Kannauj (c. 8th–10th centuries)
Why Kannauj? It was the former capital of Harsha, a symbol of supremacy over north India, and it controlled the fertile Ganga-Yamuna doab and its trade routes.
| Power | Base | Key rulers | Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Palas | Bengal and Bihar | Gopala (c. 750), Dharmapala, Devapala | Gopala was chosen by chiefs to end anarchy (matsyanyaya) — recorded in Dharmapala’s Khalimpur copper plate; Dharmapala founded Vikramashila and built the Somapura Mahavihara at Paharpur (Bangladesh); Devapala granted villages to a monastery at Nalanda built by the Sailendra king Balaputradeva of South-East Asia; great patrons of Mahayana Buddhism and of the Nalanda school of bronze and stone sculpture |
| Gurjara-Pratiharas | Western India, Malwa, later Kannauj | Nagabhata I, Nagabhata II, Mihira Bhoja, Mahendrapala I | Nagabhata I resisted the Arabs of Sindh; Nagabhata II took Kannauj; Mihira Bhoja issued Adivaraha coins and was described by the Arab merchant Sulaiman (851 CE); Mahendrapala I patronised the poet Rajashekhara (Karpuramanjari, Kavyamimamsa) |
| Rashtrakutas | Deccan; capital Manyakheta (Malkhed) | Dantidurga (founder), Krishna I, Dhruva, Govinda III, Amoghavarsha I, Krishna III | Krishna I built the rock-cut Kailasa temple (Cave 16) at Ellora; Dhruva and Govinda III raided as far as the doab; Amoghavarsha I, a patron of Jainism, is associated with the Kavirajamarga (the earliest Kannada work on poetics); Sulaiman counted the Rashtrakuta king among the four great kings of the world; Krishna III defeated the Cholas at Takkolam (949) |
Outcome: no side won permanently. By the late tenth century all three were weakened — opening the way for the Rajput states in the north, the Later Chalukyas in the Deccan and the Cholas in the south.
Rajput dynasties (c. 8th–12th centuries)
Origins: the Prithviraj Raso of Chand Bardai tells a myth of four agnikula clans born from a fire at Mount Abu (Pratiharas, Chalukyas/Solankis, Paramaras, Chahamanas). Historians variously trace Rajput origins to older local ruling families, to Central Asian groups absorbed into Indian society, and to the rise of new landed lineages.
| Dynasty | Region and capital | Ruler / monument |
|---|---|---|
| Chahamanas (Chauhans) | Shakambhari and Ajmer | Prithviraj III — won the First Battle of Tarain (1191), lost the Second (1192) |
| Paramaras | Malwa; capital Dhar | Bhoja (11th century) — scholar-king; the Bhojpur temple and lake; works on poetics and architecture attributed to him |
| Chandelas | Bundelkhand (Jejakabhukti); fort of Kalinjar | Khajuraho temples — the Lakshmana temple (Yashovarman) and the Kandariya Mahadeva temple (Vidyadhara); UNESCO World Heritage Site (1986) |
| Solankis (Chalukyas of Gujarat) | Anahilavada (Patan) | Modhera Sun Temple (Bhima I); Vimala Vasahi at Dilwara, Mount Abu, built by Bhima I’s minister Vimala; Rani ki Vav stepwell at Patan (UNESCO 2014) |
| Gahadavalas | Kannauj and Varanasi | Jayachandra — defeated by Muhammad Ghori at Chandawar (1194) |
| Tomaras | Delhi (Dhillika) | Associated with the early development of Delhi |
| Eastern Gangas (Odisha, not Rajput) | Odisha | Narasimhadeva I — Konark Sun Temple (13th century; UNESCO 1984) |
Kashmir: Kalhana’s Rajatarangini (1148–49), a verse history of Kashmir, is the closest early Indian text to modern historical writing. Kings include Lalitaditya Muktapida of the Karkota dynasty (the Martand Sun Temple) and Avantivarman of the Utpala dynasty, whose engineer Suyya carried out flood control and irrigation works.
Bengal after the Palas: the Senas — Jayadeva’s Gita Govinda was composed at the court of Lakshmana Sena.
Arabs, Ghaznavids and Ghurids
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 712 | Muhammad bin Qasim conquered Sindh, defeating King Dahir; the event is narrated in the Chachnama |
| 1000–1027 | Mahmud of Ghazni led some seventeen raids; sacked Somnath in 1025 |
| — | Al-Biruni, who came with Mahmud, wrote Kitab-ul-Hind (Tahqiq-i-Hind) — a study of Indian science, religion and society; the Persian poet Firdausi (Shahnama) was associated with Mahmud’s court |
| 1175 | Muhammad Ghori took Multan |
| 1178 | Ghori defeated by the Chalukyas (Solankis) of Gujarat near Mount Abu |
| 1191 | First Battle of Tarain — Prithviraj III defeated Ghori |
| 1192 | Second Battle of Tarain — Ghori defeated Prithviraj III; Turkish rule in north India begins |
| 1194 | Battle of Chandawar — Ghori defeated Jayachandra Gahadavala |
Why the Rajput states lost: disunity and rivalry; armies of feudal levies under samantas; reliance on elephants against fast mounted archers; outdated tactics; neglect of the north-western frontier.
The “feudal” debate
Land grants with fiscal and administrative rights, a hierarchy of samantas (subordinate chiefs), and a decline of towns and coinage have led historians such as R.S. Sharma to describe the period as one of Indian feudalism. Others (e.g. Harbans Mukhia) question whether the European term fits Indian conditions, and many historians stress instead the rise of regional states, agrarian expansion and new temple-centred economies.
graph TD
A[Harsha dies 647] --> B[Fragmentation]
B --> C[Tripartite struggle for Kannauj]
C --> D[Palas]
C --> E[Pratiharas]
C --> F[Rashtrakutas]
D --> G[Rajput and regional states]
E --> G
F --> G
G --> H[Ghaznavid raids and Ghurid conquest]
H --> I[Delhi Sultanate 1206]Memory Anchors
Tripartite powers: “Play Politics Right” → Palas (east), Pratiharas (west), Rashtrakutas (south) — all three wanting Kannauj, the “King-maker city”.
Rajput temples: “Chandela Khajuraho, Solanki Modhera, Ganga Konark” — the C-K, S-M, G-K pairs.
Travellers in sequence: Fa-Hien (Chandragupta II) → Hiuen Tsang (Harsha) → Sulaiman (Pratiharas, 851) → Al-Biruni (Mahmud of Ghazni).
For Prelims
- Harsha era begins 606 CE; Harsha defeated by Pulakeshin II on the Narmada (Aihole, 634 CE).
- Banabhatta — Harshacharita, Kadambari; Harsha wrote Ratnavali, Priyadarshika, Nagananda.
- Vikramashila and Somapura (Paharpur) — Dharmapala of the Palas.
- Kailasa temple, Ellora — Krishna I (Rashtrakuta); Kavirajamarga — associated with Amoghavarsha I.
- Rajatarangini — Kalhana, 1148–49; Gita Govinda — Jayadeva (Sena court).
- Kitab-ul-Hind — Al-Biruni; Tarain — 1191 and 1192.
For Mains
- Dimensions: political fragmentation vs cultural creativity; regional identities and languages (early Kannada, Bengali, Marathi literature); temple architecture as statecraft; monasteries and international Buddhism (Nalanda, Vikramashila and South-East Asia); the military and social causes of the Turkish success.
- Keywords: tripartite struggle, samanta, land grants, Indian feudalism, agnikula, regional kingdoms, Nagara temple.
- Value-addition: Al-Biruni’s remark on the insularity of Indian scholars of his day; Khajuraho, Konark and Rani ki Vav as World Heritage Sites; the Pala–Sailendra link at Nalanda as early cultural diplomacy.
Common Traps
Practice
Prelims
The “tripartite struggle” among the Palas, the Gurjara-Pratiharas and the Rashtrakutas was mainly for control of
Solution
Kannauj, Harsha’s capital, symbolised supremacy over north India and commanded the Ganga-Yamuna doab. Ujjain was a Pratihara stronghold, Thanesar was Harsha’s ancestral capital, and Pataliputra had declined by this period.
Answer: B
Consider the following pairs:
| Temple | Dynasty |
|---|---|
| 1. Kandariya Mahadeva, Khajuraho | Chandela |
| 2. Sun Temple, Modhera | Solanki |
| 3. Kailasa temple, Ellora | Rashtrakuta |
| 4. Sun Temple, Konark | Paramara |
How many of the pairs given above are correctly matched?
Solution
Pairs 1, 2 and 3 are correct. The Konark Sun Temple was built by Narasimhadeva I of the Eastern Ganga dynasty (13th century); the Paramaras ruled Malwa from Dhar. Three pairs are correct.
Answer: C
Consider the following statements about Harshavardhana:
- He was defeated by Pulakeshin II on the banks of the Narmada.
- His court poet Banabhatta wrote the Harshacharita.
- The Chinese pilgrim Fa-Hien visited his court.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Solution
Statements 1 and 2 are correct — the defeat is recorded in the Aihole inscription (634 CE). Statement 3 is wrong: the pilgrim at Harsha’s court was Hiuen Tsang; Fa-Hien came two centuries earlier, under Chandragupta II.
Answer: A
Mains
The period between the death of Harsha and the Turkish conquest is often described as one of political fragmentation but cultural flowering. Discuss with reference to north India.
Solution
Introduction: After Harsha (d. 647), no empire held north India for long. The tripartite struggle for Kannauj was followed by competing Rajput and regional states until the Ghurid victory at Tarain (1192).
Body — fragmentation:
- Two centuries of war among the Palas, Pratiharas and Rashtrakutas.
- Land grants and samantas — decentralised, “feudal” polities (R.S. Sharma’s view, debated).
- Rivalries that left the north-west exposed to Mahmud of Ghazni and Muhammad Ghori.
Body — flowering:
- Temples: Khajuraho (Chandelas), Modhera and Dilwara (Solankis), Konark (Eastern Gangas), Martand (Kashmir) — the Nagara style at its height.
- Learning: Nalanda and Vikramashila under the Palas; links to Tibet and South-East Asia.
- Literature: Banabhatta, Rajashekhara, Kalhana’s Rajatarangini, Jayadeva’s Gita Govinda; growth of regional languages.
- Art: Pala bronzes and manuscript painting; stepwells such as Rani ki Vav.
- Science and scholarship: royal patrons like Bhoja of the Paramaras.
Conclusion: Regional courts competed through culture as much as war; the result was a rich, regionally diverse heritage even as the political system grew vulnerable to outside conquest.
Quick Revision
| Point | One-liner |
|---|---|
| Harsha | 606–647; Kannauj; Banabhatta; Hiuen Tsang |
| Aihole inscription | 634 CE; Ravikirti; Pulakeshin II beats Harsha |
| Tripartite struggle | Palas, Pratiharas, Rashtrakutas — for Kannauj |
| Palas | Gopala elected; Vikramashila; Mahayana |
| Pratiharas | Resisted Arabs; Mihira Bhoja; Rajashekhara |
| Rashtrakutas | Manyakheta; Kailasa temple; Amoghavarsha I |
| Rajput temples | Khajuraho, Modhera, Dilwara |
| Kashmir | Rajatarangini (Kalhana, 1148–49); Martand |
| Invasions | Sindh 712; Somnath 1025; Tarain 1191, 1192 |
Key Takeaways
- Kannauj was the symbolic capital of north India; the struggle for it shaped three centuries of politics.
- Learn the dynasty–capital–monument–courtier chain for each kingdom; Prelims tests the links.
- For Mains, balance political weakness with the remarkable regional culture of the period.
Related Topics
- Southern Kingdoms and the Cholas
- Early Medieval India — quick revision
- Early Medieval India — practice questions
- The Delhi Sultanate
- Indian Art and Architecture